We were so excited to see a coffee shop come to the island! I had a blueberry donut and it was delightful! The coffee is simple yet delicious. I can’t wait to be back morning after morning supporting Lucy’s!
-Ashlyn F.
Testimonials
★★★★★
★★★★★
Absolutely the best thing to happen to our island in a while. Quality. Freshness. Fair pricing. Thanks Lucy’s!
-Marsha W.
★★★★★
It’s so nice having a quick service option on Plum Island — something we really haven’t had. The breakfast sandwiches were great (on their homemade English muffins), the raspberry scone was delicious, and the iced coffee was fine. Hoping to see an expanded coffee menu once they’re really off to the races!
-Erin L.
Contact Form
Lucy's
Lucy’s is a cozy neighborhood market known for its freshly made breakfast sandwiches, stacked deli-style lunch options, and irresistible pastries. The aroma of baked goods and freshly brewed coffee fills the air, making it the perfect spot to start your morning or grab a midday pick me up. Whether you ran out of bacon and milk for breakfast or need a sweet treat, Lucy’s has something for everyone. Pair your meal with a smooth hot coffee or a refreshing iced coffee, and you’ll see why the locals keep coming back for more.
Cuisines
Lunch
Breakfast
Hamburgers
Sandwiches
Atmosphere
Casual Dining
Chill
Food Types
Gluten Free Options
Quick Bite
Service Options
Outdoor Seating
Takeout Only
Business Hours
| Mon: | Closed |
| Tue - Fri: | 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM |
| Sat & Sun: | 8:00 AM - Noon |
Carryout Hours
| Mon: | Closed |
| Tue - Fri: | 8:00 AM - 2:30 PM |
| Sat & Sun: | 8:00 AM - 11:30 AM |
Restaurant Image
